MyGreenExpert.com

Your Guide to Environmentally Friendly and Healthy Home Building

 
Home
How To
Resources
Photo Gallery
About
Feedback

 

How To:  Choose the Best Energy Saving Appliances

Everyone has to replace an appliance now and then.  Here's my opinionated guide to selecting models that can help limit the energy consumption of appliances in your home.  I've considered Energy Star ratings, Consumer Reports' testing and brand repair data, experts' opinions, and my own experiences reviewing and using new models.

REFRIGERATORS.  After heating and cooling your home, the refrigerator is the single bigger consumer of energy in a typical home.  In 2001 refrigerator design technology improved significantly--more efficient compressors, better sealing techniques, etc.  While I'm a supporter of using most things until they wear out, if you have a pre-2001 model operating somewhere in your garage or basement, the most eco-friendly thing you can do is to get rid of it.  If you really keep it full and use it weekly, consider replacing it with a new model (and if you want energy savings, don't put it in the garage!) .  Odds are that old model is costing you more than $125-$150 a year in electricity; new Energy Star rated refrigerators typically use around half of that.  So you're not actually "saving" by running it until it dies.

Begin with the end in mind, that is, saving energy.  Choose a model with very low annual operating costs.   Scientific testing shows that side by sides (while convenient) are the most energy-draining type of refrigerator design.  Icemakers also add a considerable load to de facto energy consumption.   Did you know that Energy Star testing the US government conducts requires that icemakers be turned OFF while the testing is conducted?  Consumer Reports found in 2008 that with the icemaker running, one refrigerator model used nearly 50% more energy than advertised on its Energy Star label.  So while the Energy Star label is a good starting point, it cannot the be-all and end-all of your shopping challenge.

Look for bottom freezer and top freezer styles that use less than 450 kWh per year of electricity.  You can get this information from nonprofit The Consortium for Energy Efficiency (www.cee1.org) and the Energy Star web site (www.energystar.gov).   Select one with low energy use that meets your needs.  Remember, do not be swayed by salespeople pushing the latest features and styles when you go to the store! Avoid fancy, pricy  'boutique' brands with dual compressors--they will cost you in both the short term and the long run.

The table below present some solid choices for refrigerator/freezers for different budgets, spaces, and situations.  Because initial shipping cost and future replacement part shipping cost is part of an appliance purchase's carbon footprint, I have included products' country of origin. Bear in mind that all features are not desirable for everyone.  I warn against icemakers from an energy use perspective, for example, yet I have noted when a model lacks an icemaker under "cons" in the table, because I know most consumers find them desirable. 

 

R/F BRAND, MODEL
TYPE
PRICE
PROS
 CONS
kWh
origin
Cu. Feet/
  width in.
Frigidaire
  FRT18HS6J
  PHT2195S
Top F
          $550
 

$950

Great price
Glass shelves
Stainless ext.
No icemaker
383
408
USA
      21
     30 w
GE
  GTH22SBS
Top F
         $1300
Nice features,
Reliable
No icemaker
415
USA
24
33 w
Sun Frost
  R-16
Top F
         $3000+
Truly miserly,
Top apt choice
Manual defrost
Made in CA.
 254
USA
16
30 w
Whirlpool
  ETICHEXV
Top F
           $749
Icemaker
Plain
388
USA
21
33 w
Kitchen Aid
  KBRS19KT
Bottom F
         $1300
Solar Decathlon
top performer
No icemaker
448
USA
22
30 w
Kitchen Aid
  KBFS25EV
Bottom F
         $1800
Spacious,
Well designed,
H20 dispenser
No icemaker
474
USA
29
36 w
Liebherr
  CS2062
Bottom F
         $5000
Icemaker
High quality
Pricey
French doors
452
Swiss
24
 36 w
Jenn Air
 JCB2280HE
Side by
         $2300
Icemaker
 
510
USA
26
36 w
Kenmore
  74126*80
Side by
         $1147
Good basics
Good value
Only@Sears
508
USA
25
36 w

 

DISHWASHERS.  The newest, most efficient Energy Star rated dishwashers save over 50% on your water bill compared to dishwashers that are just 6 years old or more.  Technological improvements like computer sensors mean lower energy bills, too.  You also won't believe how quiet these models are.

If you live in an area where electricity has peak-load pricing, look for models with a delayed start feature on the electronic control panel, so you can run the wash cycle at low-demand times and save money.

Here is my selection of good models from which to choose.  The second on the list, a Bosch, is a fabulous choice, and the second-to-last, a Whirlpool, is a top value.

 

DW  BRAND/      MODEL
PRICE
  in $
PROS
CONS
kWh
per
year
origin
Energy
Cost/yr
(no H20)
Asko Encore
 3531XLHD
 1600
World’s most efficient, great 4 stemware, quiet
High Price
Must clean filter
Repair cost high
194
Sweden
$12
Bosch
 SHE33MO(2)C
  550
Ultra quiet,
Condensing dry
Great price
Must clean filter
259
Germany
$16
Kenmore
 1388 / 1398
   640
 
Adjustable rack
Delay start
No cutlery slots
304
USA
$19
Kitchen Aid
 KUDMO3FT
 1000
Delay start, econowash,
Adj/cutlry racks
Reliable brand
Pricier than some
317
USA
$20
Kitchen Aid
 KUDC03FV
  850
3 cycles
Adj/cutlry racks
Reliable brand
 
313
USA
$20
Whirlpool
 DU1061XTS
  330
Bargain for smaller households
Somewhat noisy*
330
USA
$21
Kenmore
 13749
  600
Adj racks,
Cutlery slots
Top rated by CR
 
320
USA
$20

 

WASHING MACHINES.  There is only one way to go with a new washer-- choose a front loader.  That design is simply better at cleaning clothes efficiently, using very little water and power (and you can specify gas or electric power on many new models).  Comparison of a typical new top loading machine to a new front loader shows that the front loader uses one-half the energy annually, which means a well-chosen front loading machine will pay for itself in 5 years. 

Why wait?  Start saving today with one of these great washers.

 

W  BRAND/ MODEL
TYPE &
PRICE
PROS
CONS
kWh/
year
origin
Asko W6022
HE front load
      1000
Most H2O &
Energy efficient
  model available
Capacity: 2 cu ft
? reliability  
100
Sweden
Asko W6903FI
HE front load
      2100
Sleek look/    electronic control panel inside
Capacity: 2 cu ft
? reliability 
pricey
130
Sweden
Kenmore HE5
     477##
HE front load
     1500
Capacity: 4 cu ft
  Reliable brand
Only @ Sears
pricey
136
USA
Kenmore HE2
    4674*70
    4675*70
HE front load
 
     1200
Designer color:
  dark blue
Only @ Sears
140
USA
Kenmore
    4757*70
HE front load
  850-1000
Great value
Designer color:
  dark blue
Only @ Sears
145
USA
Whirlpool
   WFW 9700V
HE front load
     1350
Most reliable brand, 4 cu ft
Designer colors
Pricey, silly
“steam” feature
144
USA
Whirlpool
   WFW8400T
HE front load
      850
Great value 
Reliable brand
4 cu ft capacity
 
156
USA
Whirlpool
 WFW  
9200 9300
9400 9500 9600
HE front load
 
   1100-1600
Diff. colors,
Many cycle choices
Trade off : energy use vs. features desired and cost
144-186
USA

 

Of course there is no 'perfect' appliance.  I hope that you will take this list of good energy saving models that meet your needs shopping with you.  Try not to get distracted by bells and whistles (like stainless steel finishes, which cost up to 20% more than black, white and beige; and 'steam' features on washing machines, for example).  Much of it is hype, unnecessary, and not energy-efficient.  Some of it is simply used to justify a higher price tag.

Next month I'll be taking a close look at the Energy Star program's ins and outs, current challenges, and possible consumer-friendly revisions.

 

 

 

eNERGY sTAR RAT    

Home | How To | Resources | Photo Gallery | About | Feedback